Witchcraft for Wayward Girls: Book Club Discussion Questions

Grady Hendrix’s Witchcraft for Wayward Girls is a dark and unsettling exploration of female friendship, power, rebellion and the consequences of challenging societal expectations. Set in 1970s Florida, the novel follows a group of pregnant teenage girls sent to a maternity home, where they are expected to quietly await childbirth and conform to the rules imposed on them. However, when they discover a mysterious book of witchcraft, they begin to uncover a world of magic, temptation and terrifying possibilities. As the girls experiment with their newfound abilities, they find themselves questioning authority, reclaiming control and discovering just how far they are willing to go.
At its heart, the novel explores the pressures placed on young women, the power of female solidarity and the consequences of seeking freedom in a world determined to control them. Blending horror, dark humour and supernatural elements, Hendrix examines themes of motherhood, independence, shame, friendship and rebellion, while questioning who gets to decide what makes a woman good or bad.
The Witchcraft for Wayward Girls book club discussion questions below have been created by our Chapter 25 team of dedicated readers. They are designed to spark conversation and explore the novel’s darker themes, from witchcraft, female empowerment and friendship to motherhood, social expectations, control and morality. Whether discussing the girls’ relationships, the symbolism of magic or the novel’s unsettling exploration of womanhood, these questions offer plenty of opportunities for a lively and thought-provoking book club discussion.
Book Club Discussion Questions:
What were your overall thoughts of the book?
Have you read any of Grady Hendrix's other books? If so, how did this one compare?
Did you find the book more frightening because of its supernatural elements, or because of the real-world issues it explores?
Did you think the supernatural elements enhanced or distracted from the real-life horrors the girls faced?
Did your opinion of any character change dramatically as the story progressed?
How important was the setting to the story? Could it have worked in another time period?
How important is friendship to the girls' survival? Do you think their relationships would have developed in the same way without the circumstances they were placed in?
The girls are often treated as problems to be managed rather than people to be understood. How does this affect the way they see themselves?
What did you think of the adults who were supposed to care for the girls? Were any of them genuinely trying to help?
How does the book explore shame, judgement, and societal expectations?
Why do you think witchcraft is so appealing to the girls? Is it the supernatural power itself, or what that power represents?
How does the idea of a “witch” change throughout the novel? Is being called a witch always presented as something negative?
How much of the girls' behaviour is a response to the way society treats them? At what point do they become responsible for their own choices?
How much do you think fear influences the adults' treatment of the girls? Are they afraid of the girls themselves, or of what the girls represent?
Who truly has power throughout the story, and how does that change? Is there a difference between protecting someone and controlling them?
Is there ever a point where revenge becomes justified in this story?
If the girls had been given more power and freedom from the beginning, do you think the story would have unfolded differently?
What do you think the book is ultimately saying about womanhood?
How did you feel about the ending? Was there a particular scene or image that has stayed with you since finishing the book? Why?







Comments